Assessing the halfway point of the NHL season reveals both surprises and disappointments for the Toronto Maple Leafs. The goaltending duo of Ilya Samsonov and Joseph Woll has emerged as a significant strength for the team, showcasing impressive performances that were previously questioned due to their lack of experience. With solid save percentages, they've contributed to the Leafs' favorable position in the standings. In contrast, the secondary scoring has not met expectations. Despite star players producing well, the team struggles to find depth scoring across its lines.

John Tavares has become a pivotal player, stepping up in the absence of Auston Matthews and leading in game-winning goals among Canadian forwards. His transition from captaincy has seemingly relieved pressure, allowing him to thrive. Meanwhile, injuries have plagued the team, notably Jake McCabe's health issues following a concussion, raising concerns about the long-term impact on the roster as the playoffs approach.